England Rout New Zealand: Can They Finally End Boom-Bust Cycle?

Published: November 22, 2026, 3:05 am

England delivered a statement performance to defeat New Zealand by a record 37-12 margin, drawing immediate comparisons to their high-profile win over the same opposition twelve months ago. The atmosphere at the stadium felt strikingly familiar, with the attendance of 81,953 matching the exact figure from the 2025 clash. The similarities to today’s 37-12 success are striking.

For supporters, the victory comes with a familiar sense of caution. Following their previous triumph against the All Blacks, England endured a dismal Six Nations campaign, fueling concerns about the team’s ability to maintain momentum. Steve Borthwick’s tenure has frequently oscillated between extremes, marked by significant peaks and frustrating troughs. It was the litmus test of their progress, after a run of victories against lesser opponents. Burned by the dismal Six Nations that followed the 2025 result, there will be a shot of caution with the celebratory drinks tonight, for England fans.

The team’s trajectory has been erratic, ranging from a stretch of five defeats in six Tests before the 2023 Rugby World Cup to a challenging second half of 2024 where they lost five consecutive matches. These setbacks were punctuated by a 12-Test winning streak at the beginning of 2025, illustrating a pattern that has often resulted in false dawns for the squad.

Despite this history, there is genuine optimism that this current side is evolving. Unlike previous iterations, this team is utilizing a distinct tactical approach and a fresh roster. It was particularly notable that the backline selected for this match featured entirely different starters compared to the group that faced New Zealand a year ago.

The 2025 victory featured Steward, Roebuck, Lawrence, Dingwall, Feyi-Waboso, Ford, and Mitchell.

In contrast, Saturday’s side relied on a different combination: Furbank, Murley, Slade, Atkinson, Joseph, Smith, and Van Poortvliet.

Had it not been for injuries, key players such as Immanuel Feyi-Waboso, Tommy Freeman, and Alex Mitchell might have potentially featured in both fixtures, highlighting the depth and tactical shifts Borthwick is implementing to finally stabilize the team’s performance levels.