Matt Dawson: England Must Stay Grounded After Record Win

Published: November 22, 2026, 8:05 pm

England’s recent record-breaking victory over New Zealand served as an enormous statement about the current state of English rugby. While such a performance two years ago might have triggered wild celebrations, Saturday’s atmosphere felt professional and focused—a simple case of a job well done. Team leaders like Maro Itoje, Ellis Genge, and Steve Borthwick expressed little surprise, suggesting the team always held this level of capability. But something feels different this time, we have had many a false dawn with Borthwick’s England. England’s backs can compete with the very best and they tore through New Zealand on multiple occasions. This is England rugby, whether you are playing in 2026 or 1926. By any stretch, england should not get carried away.

Despite the achievement, the squad must maintain their momentum. A wounded New Zealand side is expected to arrive at Allianz Stadium next Saturday seeking retribution. By matching the historic feat of the 2002 and 2003 teams that secured back-to-back Test wins against the All Blacks, England has positioned itself well. Securing a third consecutive win over New Zealand and finalizing a third-place finish would provide a vital boost heading into the 2027 Rugby World Cup in Australia. Lose, though, and it will be a waste of some great momentum. That, in itself, shows how he is learning and evolving as a head coach. We were probably looking at it thinking it was a shame that the two top teams in the world were going to be on the same side of the draw, at the beginning of the tournament.

A significant shift in this cycle is the players’ newfound sense of ownership. For me, that comes down to the players taking responsibility.

Drawing on the style of play prevalent in the Premiership, England is now producing an exciting, free-flowing brand of attacking rugby. And finally we are seeing the players take the lead on the style of rugby they want to play, many of us ex-pros called for it during the Six Nations. Credit also has to go to Borthwick for allowing the players to take control. The Six Nations was probably a big turning point.

This evolution reflects a coaching environment that encourages dialogue, with players empowered to challenge tactical decisions. Then it is never going to work, if the environment does not allow players to turn around and say ‘this isn’t going to work’.

As Matt Dawson notes, when players reach 40, 50, or even 70 caps, they often possess deeper practical insights than the coaching staff, and an environment that ignores their input is unlikely to succeed. Once players start getting 40, 50, 60 or 70 caps, they know more about certain aspects of the game than the coach because they are the ones out there experiencing it.

The current morale shift appears to have solidified following honest internal discussions prior to the Australia match. A poignant moment occurred when former England player Lewis Moody joined the team to face the haka, creating an extraordinary display of unity that honored the history of the sport. This emotional vulnerability, balanced with a quick transition into a competitive mindset, was a major factor in the team’s success. The change in mood and the feel-good factor are clear in the way England are carrying themselves. One that will stay with me until the day I die, it was a united and extraordinary moment.

However, analysts caution against over-interpreting the lopsided scoreline. Southern hemisphere teams, particularly New Zealand and South Africa, have navigated a grueling international calendar. The emotional toll of the four-test ‘Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry’ series has left these squads visibly fatigued and struggling with injuries, as seen in the Springboks’ recent performance against Ireland. The southern hemisphere teams are coming towards the end of a brutally long season.

England faces a different kind of pressure this coming weekend: the expectation of being favorites. It will be a challenging psychological test to maintain focus while New Zealand attempts to reset before their journey home. For England, the depth of the current roster is a clear positive, with at least two quality options available for every position. The focus remains on building consistent performance, as squandering this hard-won momentum would be a significant missed opportunity.